“Psychopaths should not be punished”
The other neuro problem besides free will that criminal attorneys don’t like to think about. If such behavior is scientifically - and by legal standards - accepted as a result of a brain condition/deficit, then treatment over punishment is the only ethical choice. But, how can we know if someone has the capacity to inhibit undesirable behaviors or if they are truly uncontrollable?

The central idea is to move away from retribution toward psychopaths.


Punishment may not be the best strategy and might not even be morally supported – at least, if punishment is understood as infliction of suffering to compensate for what they have done. As strange as it may sound, psychopaths deserve our compassion. Retributive impulses probably developed during natural selection as a way to deter free-riders. But psychopaths are not sufficiently sensible to threats to be deterrable. They can’t resist their impulses to hurt others as we can. [VIA, IMG]

Well, not exactly…but what about this? Is it so unreasonable that we will be eventually looking at a spectrum type psychopathy disorder, since most psychopaths are deemed successful and only a small percentage of psychopaths are violent criminals?

Psychopaths should not be punished

The other neuro problem besides free will that criminal attorneys don’t like to think about. If such behavior is scientifically - and by legal standards - accepted as a result of a brain condition/deficit, then treatment over punishment is the only ethical choice. But, how can we know if someone has the capacity to inhibit undesirable behaviors or if they are truly uncontrollable?

The central idea is to move away from retribution toward psychopaths.
Punishment may not be the best strategy and might not even be morally supported – at least, if punishment is understood as infliction of suffering to compensate for what they have done. As strange as it may sound, psychopaths deserve our compassion. Retributive impulses probably developed during natural selection as a way to deter free-riders. But psychopaths are not sufficiently sensible to threats to be deterrable. They can’t resist their impulses to hurt others as we can. [VIA, IMG]

Well, not exactly…but what about this? Is it so unreasonable that we will be eventually looking at a spectrum type psychopathy disorder, since most psychopaths are deemed successful and only a small percentage of psychopaths are violent criminals?

72 notes

Show

  1. jiaaaaaaa reblogged this from approachingsignificance
  2. rakdad reblogged this from psydoctor8
  3. soakyourfeathers reblogged this from psydoctor8 and added:
    i couldnt figure out how not to reblog that elephantman thing
  4. sexuallytransmittedvirginity reblogged this from approachingsignificance
  5. ourgreatmisfortune reblogged this from approachingsignificance
  6. neverlaugh-atlivedragons reblogged this from approachingsignificance
  7. despawndense reblogged this from approachingsignificance
  8. abittersweetdesire reblogged this from approachingsignificance
  9. nadianadirovna reblogged this from approachingsignificance
  10. selkhetti reblogged this from approachingsignificance
  11. neuropsyched reblogged this from approachingsignificance and added:
    not to go go there again, but james holmes is probably schizophrenic and nobody’s cutting him any slack. people who...
  12. approachingsignificance reblogged this from psydoctor8
  13. magnolia-grandiflorae reblogged this from psydoctor8
  14. quiffy-lad reblogged this from psydoctor8
  15. saraahlynne reblogged this from psydoctor8 and added:
    The spectrum POV is a great one, for any condition, but it doesn’t really change the ethical dilemma of whether or not...
  16. cmchildress reblogged this from psydoctor8
  17. asgodswestood reblogged this from psydoctor8
  18. alexinferno305 said: This reminded me of a speech Terrence Mckenna gave about mental disorders. He was shaming society for isolating and judging people that have schizophrenia,depression and other mental disorders very interesting speech.
  19. barbellsandbehaviorism reblogged this from psydoctor8 and added:
    Interesting topic…
  20. honeylovesham reblogged this from psydoctor8
  21. iliveinthethunderclouds reblogged this from psydoctor8
  22. icecreamandscience reblogged this from psydoctor8
  23. connorpetersbmx reblogged this from psydoctor8
  24. choppedveinsandcheese reblogged this from psydoctor8