Joy Over Osama: The Neuroscience

Another article that doesn’t entirely live up to it’s grabby headline from the WSJ. The findings are legit, but it only references one older study from ‘06, when there are newer, fresher  studies to support the point - which is that research shows that we are neurally wired (especially young men) to seek a form of justice against rule breakers and it strikes at our reward zone when it does happen, providing a sense of relief and fairness - and this is also the case when the offence committed wasn’t directed at us. 

 Apparently, we are engineered to get pleasure from punishing those who deserve to be punished. As the scientists note:

The findings of enhanced activation in ventral striatum to a signal indicating that a defector is receiving pain are in agreement with the hypothesis that humans derive satisfaction simply from seeing justice administered, even if the instrument of punishment is out of their control.

Our level of empathic concern may be intrinsically related to our sense of fairness, but it seems the reward system is more powerful, as:

…empathic responses are shaped by valuation of other people’s social behaviour, such that they empathize with fair opponents while favouring the physical punishment of unfair opponents, a finding that echoes recent evidence for altruistic punishment. Via.

Most the studies agree finding the pattern of neural preferences suggest that “people like cooperating with fair opponents but also like punishing unfair opponents”. Via. So, the question is: what does it mean when you are having these internal negotiations with yourself not to feel relief over a rule breaker getting punished?

Update: Time does a similar piece citing one of the articles I offered up here.

76 notes

Show

  1. onceuponawildflower reblogged this from psydoctor8
  2. fluck-dancer reblogged this from psydoctor8
  3. napoletano reblogged this from psydoctor8 and added:
    Interesting speculations on the neurobiology of people’s reactions to news such as the death of bin Laden. Another...
  4. clockwork-toi reblogged this from psydoctor8 and added:
    i already knew this.
  5. quite-entertaining reblogged this from psydoctor8
  6. allofthetwinklelights reblogged this from psydoctor8
  7. hellocoast reblogged this from psydoctor8
  8. vtchica reblogged this from psydoctor8
  9. motheatenmusicalbrocade reblogged this from talkingshrimp
  10. talkingshrimp reblogged this from psydoctor8
  11. theincredibledancinglawn reblogged this from psydoctor8
  12. gracielalala said: lol so timely, gracias
  13. guardtard reblogged this from psydoctor8
  14. terminalbuttons reblogged this from psydoctor8 and added:
    Definitely reading this as soon as I take a break from my date with calculus. Seems like this is in tune with my...
  15. a-symptote reblogged this from psydoctor8
  16. tinytwists reblogged this from psydoctor8
  17. 4irbursts reblogged this from psydoctor8
  18. psydoctor8 posted this